35mm · HP5 Plus · two stops
HP5 pushed to 1600 in the forest
Ten minutes off the road the path is dark, even in July. I rated HP5 at 1600 because I wanted a shutter speed I could hold, and because I have liked the grain of a hard push in a small print. What I forget, every single time, is that a push does not add light. It adds the look of having had enough, and it sends the bill to the shadows.
Rodinal was the wrong developer for a two-stop push and I used it anyway. I like the bite, and the bottle was already open. Twenty-four minutes at 1+50 is a long time to stand in a kitchen not touching the tank. I did not give it the sleepy agitation some people use to save a push. The leaves went bright. The gaps between the trunks went nearly solid. On the scan it looks harsh. At 8×10 the harshness turns into separation, and the grain looks like part of the picture rather than an accident that happened to it.
The frame on this page is not that harsh one. It is the path, where the fog took the distance and there was no sky left to burn in. I had stopped to let the meter settle, and the picture was already there. The other frame, a person walking ahead with a paper cup for a bright note, stays in the sleeve. Without the cup that one is a study of trunks, and I already have a drawer of those.
I wrote down that I would not push this film in this developer in the woods again. I also wrote down the time, because the frames I like came out of a combination I am now calling a mistake. Both lines can live on the same card.